Australia Times

United, Strong, and Free
Saturday, Mar 07, 2026

Ben Roberts-Smith Seeks Appeal Reopening After Leaked Recording Emerges

The former soldier's legal team argues for a retrial based on claims of unfair legal proceedings.
Ben Roberts-Smith, a former Australian soldier found liable for defamation, has filed a motion to reopen his appeal, asserting that he did not receive a fair legal process.

This development follows the release of an audio recording in which journalist Nick McKenzie allegedly discusses insights into Roberts-Smith's legal strategy, raising questions about potential breaches of ethical conduct.

The interlocutory application was submitted to the Federal Court as of Thursday, wherein Roberts-Smith's attorneys contend that the case should be retried in the interests of justice.

They highlight the significance of the information that was allegedly obtained improperly and not disclosed until after the trial's conclusion.

Roberts-Smith stated, "All I have ever asked for was a fair process where the truth and justice can prevail."

In response, media group Nine, which publishes _The Age_ and _The Sydney Morning Herald_, has expressed confidence in its reporting and in McKenzie, asserting that there are no ethical violations or legal privilege breaches involved in the journalist's handling of the case.

A spokesperson reiterated that claims of a miscarriage of justice are unfounded and part of ongoing narratives promoted by Roberts-Smith and his supporters.

The disputed audio, which was aired by _Sky News_, features McKenzie admitting to being briefed on favorable details regarding Roberts-Smith’s case while attempting to reassure a witness about their testimony.

In the conversation, McKenzie indicated the potential repercussions of divulging such sensitive information.

Roberts-Smith previously launched a defamation suit against Nine in 2018, contesting reports that he committed war crimes during his military service in Afghanistan from 2009 to 2012. In June 2023, following an extensive trial process, Justice Anthony Besanko ruled against Roberts-Smith, determining that the publications had convincingly demonstrated, to the civil standard of proof, his complicity in the murders of four unarmed Afghan prisoners.

Notably, the civil standard is less stringent than the criminal standard of beyond reasonable doubt.

Justice Besanko's findings also confirmed that Roberts-Smith was guilty of bullying fellow soldiers, specifically noting an incident involving a handcuffed Afghan villager, Ali Jan, whom Roberts-Smith kicked off a cliff before allegedly instructing a subordinate to shoot.

In July 2023, Roberts-Smith initiated the appeal process, subsequently requesting to incorporate additional evidence into the proceedings.

This additional evidence includes the aforementioned audio and claims that his emails were inappropriately accessed over 100 times during 2020 and 2021. Roberts-Smith's appeal aims to also formally change the grounds of appeal to reflect allegations of a miscarriage of justice.

Kerry Stokes, owner of Seven West Media, has been financing Roberts-Smith's legal expenses.

To avoid the compromise of sensitive emails related to the case, Stokes arranged to cover the total costs for both parties in late 2023.
AI Disclaimer: An advanced artificial intelligence (AI) system generated the content of this page on its own. This innovative technology conducts extensive research from a variety of reliable sources, performs rigorous fact-checking and verification, cleans up and balances biased or manipulated content, and presents a minimal factual summary that is just enough yet essential for you to function as an informed and educated citizen. Please keep in mind, however, that this system is an evolving technology, and as a result, the article may contain accidental inaccuracies or errors. We urge you to help us improve our site by reporting any inaccuracies you find using the "Contact Us" link at the bottom of this page. Your helpful feedback helps us improve our system and deliver more precise content. When you find an article of interest here, please look for the full and extensive coverage of this topic in traditional news sources, as they are written by professional journalists that we try to support, not replace. We appreciate your understanding and assistance.
Newsletter

Related Articles

0:00
0:00
Close
Australian Shares Wipe Out Tens of Billions as Middle East War and Volatile Earnings Rattle Investors
Experts Warn Australia May Face Severe Domestic Measures in Worst-Case War Scenario
Red Bull Faces Unusual Pressure at Australian Grand Prix as Rivals Close the Gap
Australian Central Bank Official Says U.S. Dollar Still Holds Safe-Haven Status for Global Investors
Australia Lodges Protest With Beijing After Close Military Helicopter Encounter Over Yellow Sea
Allied Nations Debate Building Independent Military Strength as Global Security Landscape Shifts
Australia’s Deepening Military Alliance With the United States Raises New Questions About War Risk
Mercedes and George Russell Deliver Stunning Long-Run Pace in Australia Ahead of Season Opener
US Torpedo Strike on Iranian Warship Triggers Political Debate in Australia and India
Why Europe and Australia Are Deploying Military Forces to the Middle East as the Iran Conflict Escalates
Queen Mary’s ‘Forbidden’ Crown Jewels to Remain in Denmark During Historic Australia Visit
Carney Says Canada and Australia Can ‘Set the Agenda’ in a World Facing Multiple Global Crises
Canada and Australia Call for Iran War De-Escalation While Reaffirming Global Resolve Against Tehran’s Nuclear Ambitions
Australia Declines to Confirm Whether Sailors Were on U.S. Submarine That Sank Iranian Warship
Exxon Plans First-Ever Gasoline Shipment from U.S. Gulf Coast to Australia Amid Global Supply Disruptions
Australia Bans Hizb ut-Tahrir Under New Hate Group Laws Targeting Extremist Ideologies
Australia to Join G7 Critical Minerals Alliance as Canada Pushes Strategic Resource Partnership
Australia and Canada Forge Strategic Partnership on Critical Minerals Supply
Carney Warns Global Order Is ‘Breaking Down’ in Address to Australian Parliament
Formula 1 Returns in Melbourne: Full Guide to the 2026 Australian Grand Prix Weekend
Mark Carney Speaks Candidly in Australia on Navigating Relations With Donald Trump
Flights Resume Between Middle East, China and Australia but Travel Backlog May Take Weeks to Clear
Australian and Canadian Pension Giants Sign First Cross-Border Pact to Expand Global Investment
Historic Prisoner-Built Police Barracks Near Melbourne Listed for A$1.85 Million After Restoration
Australia Deploys Crisis Consular Teams to Middle East as Thousands of Citizens Remain Stranded
Goodman Begins Construction on Major Sydney Data Centre as AI Infrastructure Boom Accelerates
Victoria Moves to Enshrine Legal Right to Work From Home in Landmark Australian Reform
Australian Superannuation Funds Deepen Global Reach With New Investment Partnership in Canada
Gary Wingrove Set to Lead KPMG Globally After Winning Leadership Contest
Australia’s Fuel Supply Buffer Explained as Government Reassures Public During Iran Crisis
FIA Relaxes Australian Grand Prix Curfew Rules as Formula 1 Teams Reroute Staff Amid Travel Disruptions
Canada’s Mark Carney Lands in Australia to Advance ‘Middle Powers’ Partnership
Australia Reassures Public Over Petrol Supply as Middle East Conflict Drives Oil Price Surge
Australia Weighs Forcing App Stores to Block AI Services Lacking Age Verification
AirAsia Expands Australian Network with New Bali Route as Darwin Services Suspended
Australia Becomes South Korea’s Leading LNG Supplier as Qatar Disruptions Reshape Energy Flows
Australia and Vietnam Eye Strategic Rare Earth Partnership to Diversify Indo-Pacific Supply Chains
Australian Defence Personnel Confirmed Safe After Drone Incident Near Dubai Military Facility
Australian Intelligence Agency Confirms Private Meeting Between President Isaac Herzog and ASIO Director-General
Formula One Deploys Charter Fleet to Overcome Travel Disruption Ahead of Australian Grand Prix
Rare ‘Blood Moon’ Total Lunar Eclipse Lights Up Skies Across the Americas, Australia and New Zealand
Australia’s SpIRIT Nanosatellite Mission Concludes After a 690-Million-Kilometre Journey
Comprehensive Schedule and Results from the AFC Women’s Asian Cup Australia 2026
Mark Carney Advances Middle Power Strategy During Pivotal Australia Visit
Iranian Australian Community Condemns Mosques’ Mourning Services After Ayatollah Khamenei’s Death
JBS Announces New B2B Ingredients Plant Investment in Australia
U.S. and Israel Intensify Strikes on Iran as Conflict Expands to Lebanon and Gulf States
Australians Set to Witness Tonight’s Rare ‘Blood Moon’ Total Lunar Eclipse
Insurers Renew Call for Multi-Billion-Dollar Australian Flood Defence Fund Amid Rising Climate Risks
Australia Confronts Mounting Economic and Strategic Pressures at Critical Juncture
×